Attacking styles and mentality in TrophyManager: which to choose
Last updated: 2026-11-19
Every TrophyManager match starts with three tactical decisions before the lineup: mentality, attacking style and focus. This guide explains when each option works and how to choose from the strength of both teams rather than gut feeling.
1. Mentality starts with a strength comparison
Mentality has seven steps, from very defensive (1) to very attacking (7), with normal (4) in the middle. The key rule:
- An attacking mentality creates more chances for both teams. An open match favours the stronger side, whose better players settle the extra chances.
- The weaker side plays defensively to keep the score and the number of chances low.
- A defensive mentality means less possession and more pressure on the opponent's forwards.
Compare the average rating (REC) of your starters with your opponent's starters in their last match. If they are clearly stronger, the realistic goal is a draw: sit deeper and keep the match closed. Away from home, be one step more careful.
2. The six attacking styles
- Balanced: suits a squad with varied skills when the opponent shows no clear weakness.
- Direct: the best choice when you are the weaker side against an attacking opponent. It suits a defensive setup with at most two forwards, and pace and technique in midfield and attack.
- Wings: needs four wide players and works when the opponent plays only two wingers, especially slow ones who tackle poorly.
- Short passing: for the stronger side with an attacking setup.
- Long balls: when the opponent's centre backs are weak in the air.
- Through balls: when the opponent has few defensive players in midfield and slow defenders. It struggles against three centre backs plus a defensive midfielder.
3. How to defend against your opponent's style
- Against Direct: sit deeper and give your most defensive players Marking and Workrate.
- Against Wings: four defensive wide players and three centre backs, with Pace and Tackling on the flanks.
- Against Short passing: crowd the centre; Positioning and Tackling for centre backs and defensive midfielders.
- Against Long balls: centre backs who are strong in the air.
- Against Through balls: cover the centre and use fast defenders.
4. Focus
Focus (balanced, left, central, right) decides where your attacks go. Target the side where the opponent defends worst: compare the pace, marking and tackling of their full backs and wingers. Remember that their left faces your right. If they play without a defensive midfielder protecting the centre, a central focus is a strong option.
Summary
- Compare strength first: the stronger side opens the match, the weaker side closes it.
- Pick the style their defence is weak against, not the one you like best.
- Aim your focus at the weakest side of their defence.
Let TacBoard do this for you
The TacBoard extension reads your matches and your opponent's matches from your own game session and turns them into this analysis automatically, with the numbers behind every suggestion.